Trade Michael Young? Not So Fast; Cliff Lee, Jonathan Papelbon Not "Untouchable" - Philliedelphia: Philadelphia Phillies News and Rumors

« Phils Lose to Padres in Disastrous Fashion | Main | Phillies Are Talking Jonathan Papelbon Trade With Red Sox And Tigers »

June 25, 2013


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Rich Wilkins

Frank, that's insane. Lumping Papelbon with Lee is nuts, for starters. You trade Papelbon for players immediately, but understand that this will require paying money to lose him. Therefore, you don't get both players and money. Second off, you can't replace Lee- there's no free agent pitcher on that level coming available soon- so unless you're writing off 2014, forget trading Lee, throw it in the trash, and move on.

More importantly, I'd trade Utley 15 times before I'd even consider trading Lee. In fact, I'd trade him or Young right now, for even just one good prospect that will make our team soon. Draft choices are dicey (see Larry Greene), while you can get a player you want dealing these guys. Dump these guys for whatever you can, same for Chooch, and let's move on.

Absolutely though, light a dumpster fire with this shitter of a team.

A Facebook User

As much as I'd hate losing Utley, with Galvis/Hernandez Chase becomes a luxury. I'd throw Delmon Young in as a bonus, and look for more bullpen/bats. Trading ANY pitching is a lose/lose situation, giving up a premiere pitcher like Cliff Lee? That's plain dumb. You have GOT to have a basis for free agents to want to come to Philly. Once it was a winning tradition, NOW? Now we need to find those pieces again!

The comments to this entry are closed.